Hayley’s mum is not alone in her concerns about the recommendations made in the recently published Milburn Review. She explains the detrimental effect this would have on her daughter, and many others in the community, and how cuts to financial support might make it harder, rather than easier, for people with muscle wasting conditions to move into work.
“Young adults with muscle wasting conditions want to work – benefit cuts will have the opposite effect”
My daughter, Hayley, is 20 years old and a full-time wheelchair user due to Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT), a progressive neuromuscular condition. She lives with chronic pain and fatigue and is currently in the penultimate year of an Economics degree.
Like many families affected by neuromuscular conditions, we have spent years encouraging independence whilst simultaneously navigating the increasing costs associated with disability.
Why cutting support will not get young disabled people into work
What concerns me most about recent benefits proposals for people under 25 is that they appear to assume that reducing financial support will encourage more young people into employment. In the case of young adults like Hayley, this assumption completely misses the point.
Hayley is already doing everything she can to prepare herself for employment. She deliberately chose Economics because it offers access to careers that are predominantly desk-based and therefore more realistic given her mobility limitations, chronic pain and fatigue. She hopes to build a career within organisations such as the NHS, Civil Service or wider public sector, where flexible and hybrid working opportunities are more likely to exist.
She wants to work. She wants to contribute to society. She wants to become financially independent. The challenge is not motivation. The challenge is managing the additional barriers and costs created by disability.
It’s so hard to find work when you’re a disabled student – PIP is essential
As a full-time wheelchair user, opportunities for student employment are significantly more limited than for many of her peers. Typical student jobs in hospitality, catering, retail and customer service frequently involve prolonged standing, lifting, carrying, accessing stock rooms and reaching high shelving.
For this reason, Personal Independence Payment (PIP) has been vital in helping Hayley maintain a degree of financial independence whilst studying. PIP is not a replacement for employment. It helps compensate for the additional costs and barriers associated with disability while she gains the qualifications needed for a sustainable career.
One-off grants cannot replace ongoing support
One aspect of the current discussion that particularly worries me is the suggestion that disability support could be replaced by a lower-value payment supplemented by one-off grants or funding schemes.
The reality of living with a neuromuscular condition is that costs do not arise once and disappear. They are ongoing, unpredictable and increase as equipment ages and mobility needs change.
For example, Hayley’s current wheelchair cost more than £10,000 and allows her to attend university, travel independently and prepare for employment. The wheelchair is now over five years old and beyond the review period that would normally be expected. We therefore have significant concerns about how a one-off funding system would operate in practice.
Would equipment of this value be funded? Who would decide? How long would applications take? What happens when essential equipment fails unexpectedly? Would support be available quickly enough to prevent interruption to education or future employment?
The ongoing costs families carry
Whilst Hayley is at university, we continue to meet numerous disability-related expenses, including stairlift servicing, wheelchair servicing and repairs, replacement tyres, replacement chargers and other equipment costs that arise as part of daily life with a neuromuscular condition.
Accessible accommodation presents another challenge. Because of her disability, Hayley cannot simply move into the cheapest accommodation available to students. Suitable accessible accommodation is limited and often significantly more expensive. As a result, there is an annual shortfall of approximately £4,500 between her student finance entitlement and the actual cost of accessible accommodation.
Mental health is just as important as physical health
I am particularly concerned that these proposals risk overlooking the wider social and emotional improvements that disability support provides.
Recently, Hayley used part of her PIP to purchase a wheelchair tennis chair. Wheelchair tennis has allowed her to participate in sport, improve her confidence, remain physically active and build friendships with people who understand the challenges of living with mobility impairment. These benefits cannot be measured purely in financial terms. They play an important role in wellbeing, social inclusion and mental health.
I struggle to see how specialist equipment of this type would fit within a one-off funding model, yet it has made a genuinely positive difference to her quality of life.
Benefits that make work possible for disabled people
My concern is that policy discussions are increasingly focused on moving people into work whilst overlooking the fact that disability support often enables people to reach the point where employment becomes possible.
Young adults with neuromuscular conditions already face additional barriers to education, employment, housing and transport. Reducing support risks creating further obstacles rather than removing them.
Hayley’s experience demonstrates that disability support is not necessarily preventing young people from participating in society. In many cases, it is the very thing that enables them to do so.
The name in this story has been changed to protect the person’s identity.
Published on Tuesday 17 November 2026, the Milburn Review laid out a “whole system reset” of the employment support and social security systems for young people, including a new benefits system for disabled people under 25.
The report proposes scrapping access to PIP and the health element of Universal Credit for that age group. However, no detail was included about who would be eligible for the new ‘Additional Costs Allowance’ and ‘Severe and Complex Needs Insurance’ that are proposed to replace these benefits.
Like Hayley’s mum, we’re concerned that many young disabled people might lose out on vital income at a time where the cost of living is hitting crisis point.
We’ll continue to analyse the report, as well as the upcoming Timms Review into PIP, and will keep you informed when additional information is made available.