On Tuesday 17 November 2026, the Milburn Review published its final report, laying out what its author, Alan Milburn, describes as a “whole system reset” of the employment support and social security systems for young people.
Reflections on the Milburn Review, and our five questions for the UK government
While we welcome some of the recommendations around supporting young disabled people into work, we’re very concerned about some of the proposals to redesign the benefits system. Here we take a closer look at what was in the report and present our five main questions for the government as it considers its response.
First, let’s look at what we welcome in Milburn’s report
The ideas for better employment support and proposed changes to the job market could, if done well, be genuinely transformative for many young disabled people.
We know that many people living with muscle wasting conditions who don’t currently work do want to, but for years they have been let down by failing employment support schemes and a lack of stable, accessible and suitable jobs they can move into. The Milburn Review is ambitious about knocking down these barriers.
It recommends big investment into better, personalised employment support and promises everyone a single named advisor and a tailored personal plan. This would be delivered by a new Youth Opportunity Service (YOS) which would be set up in every local area. Young disabled people would go to their local YOS rather than Jobcentre Plus and could also access a range of other support for things like health and wellbeing.
More flexible opportunities for work such as the Danish “Flexicurity” model the Review recommends would also be welcome. And Milburn also calls for a national disability employment target and interventions from the government to close the disability employment gap, which is still at nearly 30% and hasn’t meaningfully improved despite years of talk.
Real concerns about cuts to benefits
But for many in our community, these proposals bring little comfort against the backdrop of the Milburn Review’s recommendations to redesign the benefits system for under-25s. That’s why, in the wake of the report, people began getting in touch with us to share their concerns.
One of those was the mother of 20-year-old Hayley, who is living with Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT). She told us about the anxiety felt by her and her daughter about the impact of losing out on financial support and explains why this will make it harder, not easier, for Hayley to find work.
This mum and daughter have a lot of questions. We do too.
We’re deeply concerned that these proposals could amount to cuts and, ultimately, people living with muscle wasting conditions losing out on vital income, potentially to the tune of hundreds of pounds per month.
At this stage, the reforms are only proposals. There would be a long way to go before any measures came into force. With this in mind, we have five key questions for the UK government as it considers the findings of the Milburn Review. We’ve also explained some of the key proposals.
Our five questions for the UK government
Who and what would qualify for the new “Additional Cost Allowance”?
The Milburn Review recommends scrapping Personal Independence Payment (PIP) for disabled people under the age of 25. It suggests replacing PIP with a new “Additional Cost Allowance” to cover “significant, well-established and ongoing” disability-related costs, with some one-off costs covered by a new “Health and Disability Fund”. It’s unclear how generous this would be and who would qualify, but the report suggests that less people would receive less money overall.
We need to know who in our community would miss out if this were to be taken forward. And we need to know what would happen to the Motability Scheme and Carers’ Allowance, both of which are linked to PIP and both of which are very important to our community.
Who would be eligible for the new “Severe and Complex Needs Insurance”?
The Review also recommends scrapping the health element of Universal Credit, which can be worth up to £429 per month. It suggests replacing it with a new “Severe and Complex Needs Insurance”. But it says that this would be for a “small minority” of people who will likely never be able to work and would be set “intentionally at a very high bar”.
Before any such proposals are brought forward, we urgently need to know how many young people would be protected by this. And we need openness about what would happen to those people who find themselves unequivocally unable to work because of their muscle wasting condition but would not meet the “high bar” of eligibility the report talks about.
Who is going to lose out, and by how much?
This is the critical question which isn’t answered by the Milburn Review. It’s hard to see how the two changes above wouldn’t lead to significant amounts of young disabled people losing out on significant amounts of money. As the Institute for Fiscal Studies says, “Many young people with health conditions would get less in benefits, and only some of them would be able to offset that loss by moving into work.”
The Milburn Review predicts that its proposals over their 10-year scope would lift 50,000 people out of poverty. But we don’t know much about how it comes to that figure, what the immediate impacts would be, and whether disabled young people would be disproportionately affected. One thing we do know is the Review itself is clear: ” The changes proposed here will make some young people less well off at first”.
If the UK government decides to take these recommendations forward, it must urgently publish impact analysis on poverty and hardship, with an impact assessment specifically for young disabled people.
When would people living with muscle wasting conditions be impacted by any changes?
The report says that nobody should move into the new system or have financial support removed until “replacement support and opportunities are in place”. But what would that mean in practice? Who would decide when that point had been reached? And how would that fit with the ambitious timelines attached to these reforms?
The report says that it would want young disabled people claiming for the first time going into the new system as soon as possible after any new laws were passed, and that people on existing benefits should be migrated as soon as 2029.
Are these changes going to be limited to under-25-year-olds?
The Milburn Review’s focus on NEETs means that it mostly only makes recommendations affecting young people under-25. But significantly, it does say: “the design features of the system proposed here for young people could be applied to the older cohort of claimants.” The Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, appears to have confirmed that the government is considering applying the Review’s recommendations “right through the age range”.
We need urgent clarity on whether any new benefits system is indeed going to be for young disabled people only, or if it will end up being much wider. We also await the outcome of the separate Timms Review of PIP.
What happens next?
These are now the fundamental questions being asked by disabled people and the wider disability sector. The UK government must answer these questions as it lays out its response to the Milburn Review and brings forward its own proposals.
It must guarantee that disabled people, including people living with muscle wasting conditions, would not lose out on vital income through any reforms it brings forward. Reforms which come at a time where the cost of living is again hitting crisis point.
We applauded the government for its approach to co-production and open dialogue with disabled people through the Timms Review of PIP. It’s essential that this approach continues as it considers highly consequential recommendations for reshaping young disabled people’s social security.
We welcome the Milburn Review’s boldness in calling for radical changes to employment support, many of which our community has been calling for over many years. But this mustn’t come at the expense of young disabled people’s financial security.
We will be working hard in the coming months to ensure young people living with muscle wasting conditions can live with the financial security they need.